Super Micro Computer Inc. (NASDAQ:SMCI) has been on a turbulent ride over the last 20 months, experiencing both explosive growth and sudden setbacks. From January 2023 to March 2024, shares surged by 1,350%, fueled by the company’s role in the artificial intelligence (AI) server market. However, Super Micro Computer stock is now trading 68% below its all-time highs, leaving investors to wonder if the stock can recover by the end of 2024.

Hindenburg Research Puts Super Micro Under Scrutiny

In August, Hindenburg Research, a well-known short-seller, targeted Super Micro Computer with allegations of accounting violations, undisclosed related party transactions, and sanction violations. The accusations came at a crucial moment for the company, which was in the process of filing its 10-K annual report for fiscal 2024.

Hindenburg’s report pointed to Super Micro’s history, including a temporary delisting from the Nasdaq in 2018 due to delays in filing financial statements and a $17.5 million fine from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in 2020 for improperly recognizing $200 million in revenue. According to the report, key executives involved in the previous accounting scandal were rehired shortly after the fine, raising concerns about the company’s internal controls and financial transparency.

Super Micro swiftly denied Hindenburg’s claims, stating the report contained inaccuracies. However, the delay in filing the company’s annual report and the subsequent controversy caused investors to lose confidence, triggering a sharp decline in Super Micro Computer stock.

Investment Banks Downgrade Super Micro Computer Stock

The situation worsened as several investment banks downgraded their ratings on SMCI. Even before the short-seller report, Bank of America (NYSE:BAC) downgraded the stock from “buy” to “neutral,” citing concerns over shrinking profit margins despite robust sales growth. Super Micro’s revenue increased from $3.3 billion in 2020 to $14.94 billion in 2024, but its gross margins decreased from 15.8% to 14.1% during the same period. The margin compression has been attributed to increased competition from companies like Dell Technologies (NYSE:DELL) and Hewlett Packard Enterprise (NYSE:HP).

Bank of America noted that gross margins in Q4 of 2024 were a disappointing 11.3%, well below estimates of 13.6%. The lower margins were primarily driven by costs associated with scaling liquid cooling solutions and higher sales of lower-margin hyperscale products.

Following the release of the Hindenburg report, Barclays also downgraded Super Micro stock, lowering its rating from “overweight” to “equal-weight.” Barclays cited concerns over internal controls, declining margins, and increased working capital needs, reducing its price target from $693 to $438. JPMorgan (NYSE:JPM) followed suit, slashing its price target from $950 to $500 per share.

Analysts Weigh in on Super Micro’s Future

Despite the wave of downgrades, not all analysts are bearish on Super Micro Computer stock. Out of the 12 analysts covering the stock, four maintain a “strong buy” rating, seven recommend holding, and only one suggests a “strong sell.” The average price target remains high at $851.21, which represents a potential upside of over 118% from current levels.

This optimism stems from Super Micro’s position in the rapidly growing AI and data center markets. The company has shown strong sales growth and is considered a leader in AI-focused server solutions. Analysts who are bullish on the stock argue that if the Hindenburg allegations prove to be unfounded, the current dip could present an attractive buying opportunity for long-term investors.

Super Micro has also reassured investors that the delay in filing its annual report is not expected to have any material impact on its financials. The company remains confident in its growth prospects, projecting adjusted earnings to expand at an annual rate of 62.4% over the next five years. Additionally, the stock’s price-to-earnings ratio of 17.5x suggests that it may be undervalued relative to its growth potential.

Buy, Sell, or Hold: What Should Investors Do?

Super Micro Computer is a high-growth company that has been hit by short-term headwinds. The ongoing scrutiny from Hindenburg and investment banks has understandably shaken investor confidence, but the long-term growth story remains intact, especially as the company continues to play a critical role in the AI server market.

For investors with a higher risk tolerance, Super Micro Computer stock may be a buy, especially if the company is able to refute the accounting allegations. However, for more conservative investors, the prudent move may be to hold until there is more clarity on the outcome of these concerns. The company’s focus on AI and its impressive sales growth could drive significant long-term gains, but the risks surrounding internal controls and margin pressures must not be ignored.

In conclusion, Super Micro stock remains a promising growth play in the tech sector, but investors should proceed with caution and closely monitor the company’s financial filings and responses to the ongoing investigations.

Featured Image: Freepik

 Please See Disclaimer